CHAPTER XXIV.
The Best Remedy.
Emigration—The various Fields—Distinguish the industrious Worker in need of temporary Relief—Last Words.
All other remedies considered, we come back to that which is cheapest, most lasting,
and in every way the best—emigration.
This,
of course, as applying to unwilling and undeserved pauperism. These are the
sufferers that our colonies are waiting to receive with open arms. They don’t
want tramps and vagrants. They won’t have them, well knowing the plague such
vermin would be in a land whose fatness runs to waste. But what they are willing
to receive, gladly and hospitably, are men and women, healthy, and of a mind to
work honestly for a liberal wage. New Zealand has room for ten thousand such; so
has Australia and Canada.
It would be a happy alteration, if some milder term than
“pauper” might be invented to distinguish the industrious worker,
temporarily distressed, so as to be compelled to avail himself of a little
parochial assistance, from the confirmed and habitual recipient of the
workhouse dole. As was pertinently remarked by Colonel Maude, at a recent
meeting held in the rooms of the Society of Arts, and at which the policy of
assisting willing workers to emigrate to New Zealand was argued:
“There are people who are fond of putting forward the offensive
doctrine, that a man who is a ‘pauper,’ as they call him, has thereby become
unfit ever again to exercise the self-reliance and independence in any other
country necessary to procure him a living, the want of which qualities has
brought him to the abject condition he is now in. Like most sweeping
generalities, this is both false and cruel. The condition of the wage-paid class
is, in the nature of things, more dependent than that of any other; and without
for a moment depreciating the wisdom of frugality and thrift, I would ask some
of those who are in the enjoyment of independent incomes, whether their position
would not be almost as desperate if their income were suddenly withdrawn? And
this is constantly happening to large masses of our artisans, in many cases
entirely without fault of their own; and then how does the State deal with them?
It says, ‘If you will wait until you have parted with your last penny and your
last article of furniture, and then come to us, we will assist you, but only
then, and only in the following manner; The allowance of food, clothing, and
shelter which we will give you shall be the least which experience proves will
keep body and soul together. We will break the law of God and of nature by
separating you from your family. We will prevent you seeking for work elsewhere
by confining you in a house where employers are not likely to search for you,
and whence you cannot go to seek it yourself. The nature of the work you shall
perform shall not be that in which you are proficient, but shall be of the
most uninteresting and useless kind. Owing to the small quantity of food we give
you, you will not be able to exert your powers to their best advantage. By
resorting to us for assistance, you will be lowered in the estimation of your
fellow-workmen; and in all probability, as experience tells us, you will return
to us again and again, until you become a confirmed and helpless
pauper.’
“We are fond of pointing to Paris, and of showing how
dearly the French pay for their system of providing work for the people; but if
it be true, as I have lately heard, that there are one million of paupers at
this moment in England—and besides these, I am in a position to state that
there cannot be less than one million persons who would be glad of permanent
employment at reasonable wages —I do not think we have much to boast of.
Besides, does anyone doubt that if the French Emperor were possessed of our
illimitable colonies, with their endless varieties of climate, he would very
soon transfer his surplus population to them, and be very glad of the chance?
And we ought to consider the cost of our paupers. Let us take it at 10l.
a head per annum. As a matter of economy, it would pay very well to capitalise
this tax, and at two years’ purchase we could deport large numbers in great
comfort, and thus save a good deal of money to the ratepayers, even supposing
none of the money were ever refunded; but I hope to show how that amount would
be more than repaid. But I suppose that some people will say, ‘Your system,
then, is transportation?’ My answer might be, ‘If
you are not ashamed to impose the humiliating and unpleasant condition which
you at present force upon an applicant for relief, surely when you have
satisfied yourselves that his lot will be much happier and brighter in the new
home which you offer him, all your compunctions should vanish.’”
I have ventured to quote Colonel Maude at length, because he
is a man thoroughly conversant with the subject he treats of, and all that he
asserts may be implicitly relied on. And still once again I am tempted to let
another speak for me what perhaps I should speak for myself—the concluding
words of this my last chapter. My justification is, that all that the writer
expresses is emphatically also my opinion; and I am quite conscious of my
inability to convey it in terms at once so graphic and forcible. The gentleman
to whom I am indebted is the writer of a leader in the Times:
“Here is a mass of unwilling pauperism, stranded, so to speak, by a
receding tide of prosperity on the barren shores of this metropolis. Something
must be done with it. The other object is more important, but not so pressing.
It is, that people who cannot get on well at home, and who find all their
difficulties amounting only to this—that they have not elbow-room, and that
the ground is too thickly occupied—should be directed and even educated to
follow the instructions of Providence, and go to where there is room for them.
There is no reason why every child in this kingdom should not have the
arguments for and against emigration put before it in good time, before it
arrives at the age when choice is likely to be precipitated, and change of mind
rendered difficult.
Children in these days are taught many things, and there
really seems no reason why they should not be taught something about the
colonies, in which five millions of the British race are now prospering,
increasing, and multiplying, not to speak of the United States. But we must
return to the object more immediately pressing. It is surrounded by
difficulties, as was confessed at the Mansion House, and as is evident on the
facts of the case. But we believe it to be a case for combined operation.
Everything seems to be ready—the good men who will take the trouble, the
agency, the willing guardians, the public departments, or, at least, their
functionaries—and the colonies will not complain if we send them men willing
to work, even though they may have to learn new trades. The Boards of Guardians
and the Government will contribute, as they have contributed. But they cannot,
in sound principle, do more. The public must come forward. Sorry as we are to
say the word, there is no help for it. This is not a local, it is a national
affair. Chance has thrown these poor people where they are. It would be a good
opportunity thrown away, if this work were not done out of hand, one may say.
Here are some thousands attracted to the metropolis by its specious promises of
a long and solid prosperity. They cannot go back. They must now be passed on.
Where else to but to the colonies?
“It must be evident by this time to the poor people
themselves that they may wait and wait for years and years without getting the employment
that suits them best. The metropolitan ratepayers are losing temper, and making
themselves heard. The colonies are all calling for more men and more women, and
more children approaching the age of work. Several members of the Government
attended the meeting, either in person or by letter, with promises of money,
advice, and aid. There is the encouragement of successful millions, who within
our own lifetime have established themselves all over the world. Every cause
that operated forty years ago operates now with tenfold force. At that date the
only notion of an emigrant was a rough, misanthropical sort of man, who had read
Robinson Crusoe, and who fancied a
struggle for existence in some remote corner, with a patch of land, some small
cattle, constant hardships, occasional disasters and discoveries, welcome or
otherwise. It was not doubted for a moment that arts and sciences and
accomplishments must be left behind. There could be no Muses or Graces in that
nether world. The lady, so devoted as to share her husband’s fortune in that
self-exile, would have to cook, bake, brew, wash, sew, mend, and darn, if indeed
she could spare time from the still more necessary toil of getting something eatable
out of the earth, the river, or the sea. That was the prevailing picture of
emigrant life; and when missionary tracts and Mr. Burford’s dioramas indicated
houses, streets, and public buildings, it was still surmised that these were
flattering anticipations of what there was to be, just as one may see rows of
semi-detached villas, picturesque drives, shrubberies, miniature lakes, and
gothic churches in the window of a land-agent’s office, representing the
golden futurity of a site now covered by cattle or corn. Forty years have
passed, and where there might be then a few hard settlers, there are now cities,
towns, and villages which England might be proud of; railways, and every
possible application of art and science on a scale often exceeding our own.
Large congregations meet in handsome churches, stocks and shares are brought
and sold, machinery rattles and whizzes, ladies walk through showrooms full of
the last Parisian fashions, dinners are given worthy of our clubs, and operas
are performed in a style worthy of Covent Garden, in places where, forty years
ago, men were eating each other.”
THE END.